NEWGolden Visa Guide — Download Now · NEWBuying Property Guide — Download Now
Portugal · Dating & Relationships

Lisbon: A Love Story in Fado and Rental Contracts

Expats & Nomads · 4 min read
Day 367: I left Portugal but kept the keys. Portuguese relationships don't end—they restructure into increasingly complex arrangements that somehow work. She st

Her name was Sofia. She managed an Airbnb empire and my heart with equal efficiency.


Day 1 Met Sofia at viewing for apartment in Príncipe Real. Not her apartment. Her friend's cousin's investment property. She was just "helping." Portuguese helping: Running everything while pretending not to be involved.

"The apartment is..." she paused, "complicated."

Everything in Portugal is complicated. The apartment had no official license. The contract would be in someone else's name. I'd pay cash to a company that didn't exist.

"Is this legal?"

"It's Portugal."

That's the answer to everything. It's Portugal. Laws are suggestions. Rules are flexible. Everything works until it doesn't.

Day 15 Coffee at Fábrica. She ordered galão. I ordered the same. She laughed.

"You don't like galão."

"How do you know?"

"Your face when you drink it."

She'd been watching my face. Portuguese romance: Observing everything, mentioning nothing, until suddenly mentioning everything.

Day 23 "I have boyfriend," she said, unprompted, over pastéis de nata.

"Oh."

"In Porto."

"Oh?"

"We're..." she made a Portuguese hand gesture that could mean anything from "finished" to "married" to "transcendent."

Portuguese relationships exist in permanent uncertainty. Nobody's single. Nobody's taken. Everyone's "complicated."

Day 45 The boyfriend visited. João. Architect. Looked like Portuguese Jesus. Drove a 1993 Mercedes held together by hope.

Sofia introduced us. We had dinner. All three of us.

"You're living in the apartment?" he asked.

"Yes."

"Good. It needed someone."

He knew. I knew he knew. Sofia knew we both knew. We ate bacalhau in silence that wasn't silent—it was Portuguese communication.

Day 67 João returned to Porto. Sofia stayed.

"Don't you miss him?"

"Miss?" She considered. "We have saudade."

Saudade: Portuguese untranslatable melancholy for something that may never have existed but whose absence defines you.

"So you miss him?"

"No. We have saudade."

Portuguese emotions don't translate. They just exist in parallel to regular feelings, more complex and less actionable.

Day 89 First kiss. After three months of proximity that felt like intimacy but wasn't. Or was. Portuguese boundaries are quantum physics.

Location: Miradouro da Senhora do Monte. Sunset. Tourist couple taking selfies. Homeless man playing accordion. Perfect/horrible.

"What about João?"

"What about him?"

"Your boyfriend?"

"That's different."

Portuguese loyalty: You can love multiple people for different reasons in different ways. Jealousy is Spanish. The Portuguese just have arrangements.

Day 134 Met her family. They knew about João. They knew about me. They served both wine and judgment in equal portions.

Her mother: "You're American."

"Yes."

"Temporary."

Not a question. A statement. I was temporary. João was permanent. I was present. João was future. Everyone understood this except me.

Day 156 She had keys made for my apartment. Didn't ask. Just appeared with keys.

"In case."

"In case what?"

"In case."

Portuguese preparedness: Having keys to places you don't live, maintaining relationships you're not in, keeping options that aren't options but might be.

Day 189 João moved to Lisbon. Got a job. Sofia found him an apartment. In my building. Two floors down.

"This is weird."

"Why?"

"He's... there."

"Where else would he be?"

Portuguese practicality: Emotions don't change geography. Geography doesn't change emotions. Everything coexists.

Day 201 Dinner with Sofia, João, João's new girlfriend Teresa, and Teresa's ex-husband who was visiting from Brazil.

Portuguese social dynamics: Everyone who ever loved anyone remains in the ecosystem. Ex-boyfriends become friends. Ex-wives become family. Current lovers become future ex-somethings who'll still attend Christmas dinner.

Day 234 "I love you," I said. In English. Mistake.

"Eu gosto muito de ti," she replied. I like you very much.

"But love?"

"That's different word."

"What word?"

"Different."

Portuguese love has seventeen levels. You can die for someone at level twelve. Level seventeen is reserved for Fado singers and the sea.

Day 267 Sofia's cousin needed apartment. My rental contract was "complicated." The cousin's need was immediate. I had to leave.

"But where will I live?"

"João has room."

"Your boyfriend João?"

"Ex-boyfriend."

"Since when?"

"Tuesday."

Portuguese breakups: Happening without happening, mentioned casually, changing nothing about daily interaction.

Day 290 Moved in with João. Sofia helped. She had keys.

Living with her ex-boyfriend while dating her was peak Portuguese arrangement. João cooked. I cleaned. Sofia visited both of us separately and together.

"This is insane," I told her.

"This is Portugal."

Day 334 Sofia pregnant.

"Whose?"

"Does it matter?"

In Portugal, apparently not. Fathers are biological. Parents are whoever's around. Families are anyone who shows up regularly.

João and I painted a nursery in an apartment neither of us owned for a baby that might be either of ours or neither's.

Day 367 Left Portugal. Sofia drove me to airport. João came too. His new girlfriend Teresa waited in the car.

"You'll come back," Sofia said.

"No."

"You will. You have saudade now."

She was right. I left Portugal but kept the keys. She still texts. João sends Christmas cards. The baby looks like neither of us.

Portuguese relationships don't end. They just restructure into increasingly complex arrangements that somehow work despite making no sense.

Last week's text from Sofia: "The apartment is available again. Complicated situation. Interested?"

I'm booking flights.


One year in Lisbon's emotional bureaucracy. Names changed, complication level authentic.

Keep reading

Portugal: Saudade and Situationships →Lisbon Coworking: Premium Options Worth Considering →PORTUGAL: Spain But Cheaper And More Confusing →

Planning Your Move?

Tell us about your situation and we'll help you figure out which specialist you actually need.

Get Started — Free →